A blog about my ramblings on the various personal finance options available in India. Mind you - these are my ramblings and my ramblings alone :) the information I am providing here is not endorsed by my employer, my lawyer, my mother or anybody else for that matter. Take it with no warranty, guarantee or any other form of support from me or anybody associated with me.
Friday, April 06, 2007
The elegant investment advice
Friday, March 16, 2007
Oops! I have a long term capital loss
The way I see it, short term losses can be written off against short term gains but long term losses cannot be set off against long term gains since they are not taxable anyway! So it seems I need to just sell it and swallow my loss (and pride :-) )
Thursday, March 08, 2007
Advance tax date is approaching
Update : You can pay advance tax online at NSDL website
Monday, February 26, 2007
Tracking NSE IPOs
The NSE website lists all the currently running IPOs and when you click on any one of them it actually gives you near realtime data on how much of subscription that the particular IPO has undergone during the offer period. If I see a large (1000 - 4000%) oversubscription especially in the institutional buyer's market, I figure that the big guys with their advanced research teams have figured out something interesting in this stock so I might as well buy it.
Mind you this works most of the time especially if you are planning to sell short term. There have been spectacular failures in this approach for me in the past but hey - this isnt exactly research you know! I am OK with the results that I have seen so far.
As far as getting an allocation goes, let us not even go there....!!!
I decided to start tracking the current NSE IPOs so I can plan this game better (of course it is a game - a gambling game - don't be dumb and think we have anything that is scientific here!). To make the IPO dates public, I initially added it to Google calendar. I am adding a link to the same on the right. If you use google calendars to track any of your dates, just clicking on the button will add my calendar to your list of available calendars.
Monday, February 19, 2007
What is your asset allocation
F&O Market investments
Stocks (Shares/IPO)
Bonds (RBI, ICICI, REC etc.,)
Fixed deposits (Banks , third parties)
Equity Mutual funds
Debt mutual funds
Post office (POMIS)
Real estate (Apartments, vacant land)
Please dont post the actual amounts just the % distribution.
Sunday, February 18, 2007
Must read for global Indians
http://www.rbi.org.in/scripts/FAQForex.aspx
Thursday, February 15, 2007
Mutual funds - Growth vs Dividend - What should we choose?
Indian tax laws for equity mutual funds (funds that invest > 65% of their corpus on common stock) specify that
- Short term ( less than one year) capital gains tax is 10%
- Long term capital gains is 0%
- Dividends paid are non-taxable
- Security transaction tax (STT) of 0.1% has to be paid on all SELL transactions
Indian tax laws for debt mutual funds specify
- Short term capital gains is treated as income (basically added to salary and taxed at the tax bracket you belong to)
- Long term capital gains is 10%
- Dividends paid are non-taxable in the hands of the investor but they undergo a tax called dividend distribution tax (DDT) (12.5% + surcharge + education cess) that the fund has to pay before declaring dividend. This effectively reduces the quantum of the dividend in your hands
- There is no STT.
So if you are in the highest tax bracket, it might make sense to opt for the dividend option when you are buying debt mutual funds since effectively you pay onl 13.xx% as tax on the dividend as DDT as compared to growth option.
For equity mutual funds, the verdict is very clear folks - growth is the direction in which you should be going.
Sunday, February 11, 2007
Gold Funds - an update
- Their offering is an ETF meaning - it will be traded on the stock exchange (NSE) after the new fund offer (NFO) period (between February 15 and 23rd, 2007) like any other stock.
- The "face value" is Rs. 100/- for 1 gram of gold and today's market price (say Rs 860/gm) would mean that the units are sold at a "premium" over the FV of Rs 760/-
- You can buy and sell the units of the MF on the exchange and you can also choose to get physical delivery of the gold or decide to deposit gold to obtain units (no details on how the logistics will work here)
- Fees:Investment management fees is 1.25% p.a. of the weekly average net assets outstanding for amounts up to Rs.100 Crores and 1.00% p.a. of the weekly average net assets outstanding for amounts above Rs. 100 Crores. There is no entry/exit load post listing for the fund but you will end up paying brokerage since these transactions are treated as stock. During NFO, the entry load is 1.5% upto 50L of investment
- The custodian (person responsible for managing the physical gold) is The Bank of Nova Scotia
- The scheme will have 90%-100% of their portfolio in physical gold and 0%-10% in Money Market instruments, Securitised Debts, Bonds and cash
- NAV : NAV will be calculated like any other mutual fund and will include all the expenses of the AMC. But they have the concept of a "creation unit" which represents 1000 units plus some cash component which is equivalent to apparently 1KG of gold. This creation unit applies only when you exchange physical gold for the Bees units. This is a facility available only to authorized participants (how are they determined? I dont have a clue!). So when an authorized participant reedems one creation unit he receives 1 KG of gold. I did'nt quite understand their example of buying creation units by depositing gold on Pg 26 (why did the assumption of price of gold drop to 850 from 860?). If someone can figure it out, let me know.
- You can pledge these units similar to the loan against shares schemes.
- Tax : This fund will be treated as a mutual fund other than equity which means that it will not get the benefit of short term (10%) and long term (0%) tax rates.
Well thats all for now folks. Please add your comments if you found more information.
Friday, February 09, 2007
Gold funds in India - Unanswered questions
- What is the tax implication for buying gold? Do we get tax rebates for buying a gold MF?
- Would a gold MF be treated as an equity MF or a debt MF with associated tax implications?
- When I sell my holding in the fund, do I have any extra exit loads because of liquidity risks?
- Will the price of the fund ever differ from the gold price? Considering this is more liquid than physical gold and traded mostly electronically, I would imagine that such advantages should allow the price of the fund to be at a premium to actual gold. Would this be the case?
You can always buy gold in T.Nagar... that institution would exist as long as Indians abound!
Thursday, February 08, 2007
A new year resolution - Write more blog
Thursday, September 07, 2006
How to get financially organised - A practical way for today's lifestyle
Honestly, this article is a bit of a disappointment. The ideas present here is obviously important ie. the very act of keeping records and managing them better but hey cant we actually think a little better and manage our information clutter better if we apply technology to it better (don't tell me you hate technology - what are you doing reading blogs on the internet anyway :-) ?)
So what is really a more improved way of managing better - well let us start with some of the key needs and find a solution that fits the model.
I am a guy who is on the road all the time - I travel both nationally and internationally all the time and just like the average Joe (or Rama/krishna - take your pick), I get my regular set of bank statements, taxes and all the wonderful things that this article talks about.
So how do you figure out what is your advance tax payment on the Sept 15th (you knew that was the due date right?) if you are sitting in a hotel room in wisconsin? All those statements are safely filed away in your home in India while you are on a critical 2 week business trip that falls on the advance tax date!
Also we do keep getting wonderful notices about providing PAN details since we spent over 1 lakh in a year on credit card statements from the tax departments. If you have to pay for hotel rooms in Bangalore with your credit card as frequently as I do, guess what - 1 lakh per annum is not a big number that you think it is. The only good part is that my employer picks up the bill eventually but the credit card is in my name! So we are off scrambling to track down all those old credit card statements by asking our spouses on the phone to dig up from all those files around the house! Where did we file them anyway - or did we?
So here is the bunch of tricks that I have adopted that serves me well.
Step 1 : Get a tax accountant who can actually communicate via email : Yes this is important folks - they know their Form 2Ds but when it comes to email, there is a real challenge for you. Talk to them, test them out with a few emails and make sure they do check on a regular basis and respond back to you. If you cross that first hurdle, you have got a great start.
Step 2 : Get a good image scanner or a digital camera : When I am vaulting around the world, nothing beats the advantage of my wife sending me an e-mail with a couple of JPEG attachments saying - "hey I got these in the mail today from the dept. of tax - they look important - what do you want me to do ?" instead of "I received some letter from the tax department about your credit card. I just put it in your file! You can look at it when you get back". If you combine the Step 1 with this, I just forward the scanned attachment to my tax consultant with a note asking him deal with it while I am stuck wherever I am!
Step 3 : Tell all the banks to send you monthly electronic statements. Download them into a directory and let the Google desktop loose on them. When the tax department asks you about that Rs. 113485.33 transaction that you did, Google desktop will find it for you in milliseconds!
Step 4 : Get truecrypt Its a wonderful piece of encryption software that I have trusted my financial life to! No.. I am not associated with it in any way (I am just jealous that I didn't invent it ..) its open source, very stable , haven't lost data on me so far. Read the documentation carefully, set it up and keep all your statements inside it. You would be dumb to keep it on your harddisk without protection. So you have been warned
Step 5 : Digitize all your key documents - PAN cards, tax filing from last year etc.. etc., - You know what is important to you and even if you don't think it is not so important, go ahead and do it anyway, harddisk is cheap and Google desktop can do magic on large data sets! Also now if you ever need that "Xerox copy" the nearest printer is your best friend!
Step 6 : Prepare a good spreadsheet on key large transactions (when did you do it, which account, which cheque number, why did you do it etc.,) and keep it in the truecrypt volume. Or better yet, download your electornic bank statement and load it into an Excel spreadsheet. write a detailed comment against some of the large transactions (> 50K is a good metric) and save it away. Next index by Google will catch it.
step 7 : Keep another spreadsheet on the stock transactions that you did - helps to deal with those pesky tax returns quickly! Send it to your accountant by email and tell him to figure out the taxes!
step 8 : Backup the truecrypt volume REGULARLY in multiple locations - Home PC, your pen drive, your spouse's pen drive and a monthly backup CD burned and placed in a safety locker - trust me hard disks crash ALL THE TIME.
Thats all folks - you are ready and better organized than most financial institutions!
If you really look what I have preached here, the trick of the trade is to go electronic and combine it with a good search and you can get answers faster than tax man comes asking you questions! Not that you should not keep the hard copies but just don't depend on being able to quickly find out the details!
Good luck and get organized!
Wednesday, April 05, 2006
Welcome Indian banking customer and BTW scr...w you
So who decided to shut down the automated computer systems that process these transactions? What if this was not a home loan but a financial payment to pay a college tution or a payment for a hospitalization service ie. a critical need for the customer? Why did they decide to play Gods? I suppose such things are not a big deal for them anyway. They are after all a publicly traded company and they have shareholders who can be taken for a ride while they are busy messing with their customer's money.
Morale of the story - Private banks will potentially run away with your money while the nationalized ones will simply sit on it and torment you. So dont keep all your eggs in one basket.
Amen!
Friday, March 31, 2006
How do you protect your house if you die
The article seems to explore the various insurance options available in the US for such an eventuality scenario - mortgage insurance vs. term insurance. In India I have not heard of mortgage insurance as an option. I know that Banks - to protect their loans from Natural calamity, make all borrowers sign up for a property insurance that will take care of any acts of God. I think the borrower - to protect the investment he/she has made over time should obtain varying covers to ensure that he/she can ensure that the property remains with loved ones if there is a sudden demise.
The problem is that home loans decrease over time since we tend to pay off the loan over time. How do we create an insurance plan whose sum assured also drops off over time? The solution is to take multiple insurance plans each with different timeframes. For example if your loan liability is 10Lakhs, your monthly EMI would be about 10,000 PM of which about 20% would be towards the principal and the rest towards the interest in the early years. Thus you can at best pay off about 2L at the end of five years, another 2 L after another 5 years and so on.
So the best bet is to take on multiple TERM insurance plans, each of 2L in value such that the first one expires after 5 years, the second after 10 and so on while the last one is for a period of your total loan. This will ensure that
- Your insurance payment liability drops off as your loan amount decreases
- You insure for the highest amount when you are young - when the premium tends to be lower
I didnt have this level of clarity when I took a term insurance for myself when I bought my home so today I have a large term insurance but my home liability has dropped over time. Hopefully you can plan your purchases better.
Monday, February 06, 2006
Sensex hitting 10K - should we be happy?
I am not able to share this conviction with the professionals. As a retail investor I am not comfortable with our growth story for various reasons. Maybe they are right and maybe I am naive - let me explain my stand on this based on what I have learnt by burning my fingers many a time on markets due to my naivete. One of the realities of today's financial markets around the world is this - no country is an island. A change in Japanese foreign policy will have an effect on US markets and similarly a floods in South America will affect coffee prices throughout the world. So let us for a minute look at the events world over -
- Oil prices have been on the raise we seem to be at $65 / barrel - there is no way it is going back to the $40 / barrel prices in near future unless there is a major collapse in a major oil consuming economy like the US
- We will have a stable government for the next few years - there is already rumblings in the government with the left and their constant bickering about various financial changes that the government today is bringing about does have its fair share of opposition
- There seems to be no bad news worth stopping this market - We had one of the worst floods hit various parts of our country this year and when the entire city including where I live was floating on water, the market also kept floating without even a blink. A country where the agrarian economy still rules supreme, how can such news be discounted so easily?
I guess I can keep giving more broad market examples but I want to complete this post with a simple example that really scared me - I read this article on valueresearchonline.com - They rank various equity funds on their annual performance. They rank 106 equity mutual funds and guess what was the return of the 106th fund? - well it was 26% for last financial year! Guess what folks - that sounds too good to be true.
Good luck to you - In my world today, cash is the king! Post your comments on what you think about the market and my thoughts
Sunday, February 05, 2006
The FIFO algorithm for selling Shares
The CBDT's Circular No. 768 of June 24, 1998, has clarified the method of working the period of holding. In such cases the circular envisages three situations:
When an investor holds part of his holding in dematerialised form, the FIFO method will be applicable only in respect of the dematerialised holding. This is so because in such a case, sale of dematerialised shares cannot be mixed with sale of shares held in physical form
When an investor holds dematerialised shares in more than one account or depository, the FIFO method will be applied account-wise as securities lying in another account of the same investor cannot be construed to have been sold as they continue to remain in that account
Where there is an existing account of dematerialised stock, old physical stock is dematerialised and entered at a later date, the securities first credited to the account, will be deemed to have been sold. The date from which this is held will, however, be reckoned, not from the date of dematerialisation, but from the date of purchase.
Friday, January 06, 2006
Rediff Personal Finance, ELSS and everything else
Today I found an article on ELSS, how does it help the common man due to the 80C tax savings rule but goes even further to understand how to pick out of the whole bunch of ELSS funds that is currently available in the market and makes specific suggestions on how to go about doing it.
Do not put all your funds into a single scheme; have a mix of fund houses as well as schemes.
[Via rediff: Personal Finance]
Now I have some amount of personal experience with ELSS that I wanted to share with all of you. I have been a regular investor in ELSS schemes from 2002 and so come 2005, I had the ability to actually pull my money out since the three year lockin was complete.
Now here is the interesting part - I had actually chosen 3 years ago to use the dividend option with dividend reinvestment so over the three years the fund had reinvested all the earned dividends back into the fund. The only problem is that when I tried to sell all my holding, I was told that I cannot do it since the dividends were invested at a later point in time and those units cannot be withdrawn now and that they need to go through the three year lock in period. That does make sense when we look at it but 3 years ago when ELSS was a blip in investor's radar, the people who were selling it didn't think up of this problem and neither did I.
The flip side is that I did withdraw a significant portion of the money at the beginning of 2005 and now the remaining money has grown a lot better than the money I withdrew thanks to the spectacular performance of the ELSS funds over the one year boom in the Indian stock market.
So the moral of the story folks is that opt for the "GROWTH" option if you don't want to keep track of all the pesky dividends which will pay dividends which will pay dividends etc., for ever (hopefully)
Thursday, January 05, 2006
RE: Art, now a big investment option
With stock markets being a gamble and savings fetching low returns, those with the extra moolah are adding art to their portfolio, in order to make more profits with less risk.
[Via rediff: Personal Finance]
This got me thinking about what are the choices that a retail investor has in terms of asset class in India. I am able to count the traditional choices today.
- The stock market : Today it is the hottest thing and also reached some dizzy heights.
- The bond market : Currently in a squalor due to escalating oil prices and falling US $.
- Real estate : Another poorly regulated asset class in India with lots of opportunity. Here information (or rather the lack of it) is hindering good growth.
- Jewellery: Long considered the key to savings by traditional Indian middle class, I think this sector stil shines bright in this country. The current escalating global gold prices is also helping the case.
There are other non-traditional investment classes that have caught the investor's fancy in recent times. They are
- art : The Rediff article says it all
- wine : This is another interesting asset class where there is a potential to capitalize on rare and specialized wines. In the US markets, there are actually Wine funds that can help this cause.
So there you folks, options and more options. Decide what works best for you.
Sunday, September 25, 2005
Cost of labour in India
This came as a revelation to me since I have seen the cost of labour being extremely high in developed nations leading to economic models where buying a new product is cheaper than getting an existing one fixed due to the cost of labour required to fix it. It looks like we are also moving in the same direction. How would the middle class indian society adopt to this kind of change? I am not sure. Maybe they will become more self reliant and move away from the hired help model? That I am afraid would actually reduce the number of available job opportunity which could mean a bad thing.
Whatever be our evolution path, I think that labour costs are going to raise to very high levels in the future and we need to learn to cope with it in new ways than what we have done before. Maybe the world of kaamvalis will be gone for good.
Friday, July 08, 2005
Mutual Funds - The indian scenario
Thursday, June 16, 2005
RE: Invest in art, get fantastic returns!
Art as an investment is an increasing area of interest for many financial institutions, high net worth individuals and even connoisseurs of art.
[Via rediff: Personal Finance]
Also in the economic times, I read the headline yesterday that investor wealth jumped by something like 18K crore due to the current boom in the market - obviously we indians have a lot of disposable money now and so we have a unique problem - where do we wisely invest our money? Thus avenues such as art start appearing as investment options. Is this good or bad? Only time will tell.
Monday, June 13, 2005
Fixed deposits - Are they really worth it?
- Philosophy 1: Quick access to money for emergencies : One of the key principles of creating an FD is the fact that we need quick access to money for emergencies. So much of money does one need for quick access? If you have a formula for it, great otherwise a 3 month salary would be a good yardstick to use. Anything beyond that in a FD would be underutilized funds.
- Philosophy 2: Safe and secure returns : This is a bit of a misnomer. If you had followed the logic in the first paragraph, there is no " real return" from a FD post inflation. At best you can feel that your money has not vanished but it is still around. A lot of people found out this is not true during the days when companies that offered fixed deposit vanished overnight.
- philosophy 3: Temporary parking space of excess cash:A lot of people park excess cash in FDs for short periods as a temporary parking space until they find better investment opportunities. This is a good practice since the returns from a savings account is a lot less than what at 3 - 6 month FD can give you. Interestingly there are new and better avenues to park cash.
Now that we have reviewed what the primary goals for having an FD are, let us explore what are the options available to satisfy these goals to better manage our money.
- Philosophy 1: Quick access to money for emergencies : To have quick access to cash (< 8 hours), there are very few options available in the market other than a fixed deposit linked savings account. Most banks have such accounts where the money is transparently swept into a FD from the savings account until you attempt to withdraw the money. At that point in time the FDs are "broken" to handle the request. Having said that FDs are the traditional option here, there are a few other options that one can look at to get better benefit. Credit cards provide access to reasonably large sum of money without physically having money available until the next billing cycle. Thus make your emergency payment through a credit card and then when it is time to pay those credit card bills (typically within the month) you access your funds from other sources and pay the card off.
- Philosophy 2:Safe and Secure Returns : In today's world this is hard to come by but there are various options out there that can provide this option for your money with reasonably higher return than the FD. The post office monthly income scheme (POMIS) is a good option here - it is guaranteed by the government so it is as safe as it can be. it pays 8% returns with 10% additional maturity bonus thus a higher effective rate than the average FD. In terms of liquidity, it does not score well - it does allow encashment after 1 year but the penalty clause of 5% of principal is pretty high. Investors have to wait for 3 years if they wish to close without penalty.
Investors who are able to digest slightly higher risks can look at debt mutual funds. They provide good liquidity and sometimes very good returns but these instruments are fundamentally more risky than a government backed investment schemes - Philosophy 3: Temporary parking of excess cash : If you are one of those fortunate souls that has excess money that should be temporarily parked, you should explore the following options - Liquid mutual funds with their typically better returns than FDs will offer a good parking space for cash. They are highly liquid (you will get your money in a couple of days) and unlike a few FDs, there wont by any clauses for sudden exit. They thrive on the ability to provide parking space for large amounts of cash.
With this we have explored various options for money management beyond Fixed deposits. Hope you folks get into active money management beyond FDs through the various routes mentioned here. Do send in comments and feedback if you have other means/options of managing your funds.
Wednesday, June 08, 2005
Credit rating - The new Mantra in India
personal finance in india
Sunday, June 05, 2005
Buying property in India - The common man's guide - Part 3
- Get an encumberence certificate : If you get an EC after a week of registration, it will typically contain your name on it. That is a good indication that you own the property :) .
- Get a Patta : The patta is another significant document that will reinforce the fact that the ownership of the property is registered in your name. You can typically get a patta in Tamil Nadu in 2-3 months. I suggest you apply for one soon.
Thats all there is to it. Good luck with property buying!
Thursday, June 02, 2005
An interesting approach to Investing
Many of us trade in stocks becos our friends told us to do so or found the recommendation on some business channel or trade magazine. But this is not an intelligent investment. The Internet so full of information that you can at-least do some basic research there and back up your decision with info you have researched
I am not into stocks. I am not a stock savvy person. So dont treat this as a very serious advice. But this way of gathering information is just another way of cross-verification and company profile research.
I have used Google for in genereal web search and Google News for finding the latest information from various news sources around the world. The other most important tool is the company website itself, from where you will get the pointers what to search ?
[Via IndusNeXus.com (beta) - Free Social & Business Networking | Community Blogging | India ]
Buying property in India - The common man's guide - Part 2
First let us cover the buyer (you ) scenarios. There are basically two options here, you pay for the property yourself or you have a bank fund the purchase.
- Funding yourself : If you are funding it yourself, you will have to have a legal document signed with the seller - this document is called as the sale deed. It is a legal document that will be printed on stamp paper and will describe the property and its surroundings. Then it would clearly describe the fact that the seller is selling the property to the buyer. This document should first be reviewed by the lawyer before it is executed on the stamp paper. So ask the seller or the VENDOR for a draft copy of the sale deed and have your lawyer review it and suggest corrections if any.
- Funding through a bank: Banks offer loans to purchase realty. The process they undertake would be to do a verification of the property papers (legal review through their lawyers), verify if the property price as negotiated by you with the seller is fair market value (through a property surveyor) and finally ensure that there is an agreement of sale between the seller and buyer, executed by the seller or his representative. Once they are satisfied with the three steps, the will finance the purchase and have you execute the registration process through the sale deed (similar to funding yourself). The only difference being that they will have physical possession of the sale deed until the loan is repaid.
During the registration process there are a few items you need to verify to ensure that there are no hitches in the future for the property ownership.
- Registration Price :The price quoted in the sale deed. Ideally this price would exactly match what you pay for purchasing the property. In reality though, this seems to be hardly the case when I spoke to a few buyers and sellers . You should ensure that the difference is not too large for the simple reason that you are paying a higher price for purchasing than what is being registered for would mean that if you decide to sell the property in the future, the net gain on which you pay tax is higher than what it really should be. Further the logic of reduced cost in the sale deed to reduce registration cost (which is a % of the sale price) escapes me since what you gain marginally in registration costs you pay a substantially higher penalty during a future re-sale of the property - bottomline it is not worth the trouble.
- Execution of sale:The sale execution, the process of signature on the sale deed at the registrar office should be done by you and the seller or an authorized representative of the seller. Nobody else is authorized to sign this document from either yourself or the seller's behalf. Ensure that the power of attorney given by the seller to the authorized representative is valid on the day of sale registration.
Congrats, you have now completed the sale and own the property. In the next article in this series I will cover the post sale steps that you need to take to protect your property.